Whiskeyed Peach Popsicles (PopPop’s Pops)

Private Chef Chronicles: Summering in the Hamptons (Part 3!)

Well, oy.

The thing about private cheffing is, at least in my experience, it involves food. I mean, SO. MUCH. FOOD.


banana toffee cupcakes
oreo cupcakes
oven-roasted bbq babyback ribs
blueberry frangipane tart
the makings of a damn good egg salad
peanut butter and jam cookies
blueberry muffin
strawberry short cake
salad with shaved radishes, fried shallots and carrot-ginger dressing
blueberry banana cake
red velvet cupcakes
with vanilla-mascarpone frosting
carrot mint salad with lemon vinaigrette
tomato and mozzerella salad… for 30
sliced sirloin, carrot salad, and crispy oven potatoes
various forms of chocolate-dippery. diptitude.
cobb salad


apricot cherry cream scones

Yeah. That’s just the tip of the iceberg.

Some days, I feel like I’m simultaneously running a bakeshop, a 24-hour diner and a full-service catering company. Last weekend I cooked for a party of 35. Luckily, my sister came to help me, (I made her slice potatoes for an hour straight – sorry, Case), because if she hadn’t come I might have curled up in a ball and melted into a puddle of tears on the kitchen floor. Instead, all 35 guests were fed (well fed, I should say), and neither Casey nor I am any worse for the wear.

I am, however, feeling just a little bit burnt out, which is probably why I’ve started experimenting with popsicles.

On my days off and in my free time (free time?! hilarious), I’ve been taking some of my favorite summer fruits and converting them into the coolest, most delicious popsicles.

So far I’ve made strawberry basil pops (yum, see above), cherry wine pops (used too much wine, oops), honeydew lime pops (mouth-puckering and zippy) and, my favorite, whiskeyed peach pops.

To me, the peach popsicles taste the most like summer.

When I was a kid on summer vacation, my mom’s dad, Grandpa Arnie (PopPop), used to make us sweet, frosty drinks with fresh peaches, crushed ice and, in true Arnie fashion, lots of alcohol. (For the adults, I mean. Mostly. ). PopPop didn’t spend much time in the kitchen (the closest he really got was the porch right outside the kitchen, where he stood his post as family rib-barbecuing afficionado), so these were a real treat. PopPop was a big time golfer and liked to spend most of his time outside, usually fixing things. He once held his breath so long fixing the drain at the bottom of the pool I thought he’d drowned – as I leaned over to see if the drain had swallowed him up, he popped up from the bottom and, grinning, spit a mouthful of pool water at me.

PopPop’s not around anymore, but these popsicles remind me of him. So, naturally, I think they’re the best.

Whiskeyed Peach Popsicles (PopPop Pops)


  • 4-5 ripe peaches
  • 1/2 cup greek yogurt (nonfat or regular)
  • 1 tablespoon fresh lemon juice
  • 1 cup water
  • 1 cup sugar
  • a handful of fresh ginger, cut into small pieces (it’s okay to leave it unpeeled)
  • 3 tablespoons whiskey


First, make a ginger simple syrup: Combine the water, sugar, and ginger in a small pot over a high flame. Once the mixture boils, turn off the heat and let the ginger steep in the cooling syrup for a half hour. Strain the ginger from the syrup and place the syrup in the fridge to cool. (Note: if possible, do this step ahead of time – it really speeds up the popsicle-making process. Simple syrup will last weeks in the refrigerator).

Cut the peaches, working around the pit, into wedges (no need for nice, even pieces… if the peaches start to fall apart, that’s fine). Then, peel the skin from each wedge. (If this is too difficult because the peaches are too ripe, don’t worry about it. A bit of peach skin never hurt anyone. Or any popsicles, for that matter.)

Put the peach pieces into a food processor with the yogurt, lemon juice, whiskey, and about 3/4 cup of simple syrup (more if the peaches are under ripe, less if they’re super sweet). Pulse until well-mixed.

Pour the mixture into small plastic cups (I used 3 ounce plastic solo cups. It’s nice to know that solo cups have a place in my life, even after college.) and put the cups in the freezer to chill. After an hour of chilling time, stick one popsicle stick into each cup, and put the cups back in the freezer. Let the popsicles chill overnight to fully harden. When you want to eat one, run the plastic cup under a bit of hot water to loosen popsicle, and the pop should twist right out. Enjoy with good weather and a bunch of free time.

Makes about 15 small (3-ounce) popsicles.

This entry was posted in Snacks. Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to Whiskeyed Peach Popsicles (PopPop’s Pops)

  1. Liz Gutman says:

    your posts are so delightful, my dear. gorgeous food, gorgeous photos…and the PopPop Pops look fantastic!

    has Jen ever sung you the Banoffee song from Per Se? you should ask her when you get back…

  2. P-Mapes says:

    Moll!! Oh my goodness, you poor thing! It does look and sound like you're "cooking for the 5,000" (as my Dad used to say.) It all looks so delicious. You must be incredibly proud of yourself… I know I would be. Keep going, kitchen goddess. Summer's almost over! Oh, and I love banoffee. Whiskey and peaches sounds pretty darn good too.

  3. molly says:

    Liz – thank you my dear! I will definitely ask Jen to sing the banoffee song when I get back… I mean, I know how she loves to sing in public.

    P.Mapes – speaking of kitchen goddesses, how are you?? Let's make a plan to catch up when this gig is over and I'm back in the city!

  4. Anonymous says:

    OMG…your pictures are delicious. We were in Pensacola, Fl for a baseball tournament and found a new organic popsicle shop in Pensacola Beach that has just opened named BeachPops. They had over 24 flavors and most(I didn't get to try everyone) were outrageously delicious! This took me back to my childhood. I am planning on trying your recipe. I hope it makes me feel like a kid again. Thanks ;^)

  5. Jane says:

    hi chef molly! my last post never got posted! You are simply incredible! will definitely try the popsicles! can't wait to see some of your fall recipes! love and miss you! xoxox

  6. I don’t even know how I ended up here, but I thought this post was great. I don’t know who you are but definitely you are going to a famous blogger if you aren’t already 😉 Cheers!

  7. Pingback: Summer Corn Salad » Dunk & Crumble

  8. Pingback: POPSICLE WEEK! » Dunk & Crumble

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *